Debunking the Blind Faith of Hebrews 11:1

Warning: this will bake your noodle.

It has been suggested that the definition of faith is believing in something without proof or evidence to substantiate said thing: a typical Evangelical Christian definition based chiefly on a verse found somewhere in the book of Hebrews (chapter 11, verse 1, to be precise).

However, I would suggest that there’s not only archeological evidence but also other tangible evidence that God is and keeps His word—the Bible, right?

After all, some say that today, God only speaks to us through the Bible.

So then, how is the Bible used, and what does it have to do with blind faith?

We use it as a historical record illustrating that God is trustworthy and His nature is Good. By any definition of the word, the Bible becomes our record of evidence of His existence and nature. But therein is the rub.

Using their definition, that faith must be blind, that faith must not rely on tangible evidence, then believing in and trusting God solely based on what one has read in the Bible does not constitute an application of faith, because – according to them – the very essence of faith must transcend the need for empirical validation resting instead on a profound sense of trust and conviction that is literally based upon nothing:

Now faith is the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen.

They Believe that Faith Must be Blind

What we see, then, is that these people try to define faith as empty and convince you that faith is blind. They take Hebrews 11:1 out of context and propose a new, seemingly better definition.

However, in adhering to their wishes and using their own definitions, we discover their blindness to the very nature of their origins.

What do they possess, then? Nothing more than a commitment to a logical conclusion drawn from historical evidence found in both the Bible and extrabiblical sources – because their faith must be blind and based upon no observable evidence at all.

Really Understanding Faith

While our reference to the text of the Book of Hebrews is correct, and the words found therein are true, we must move beyond blind, unsubstantiated faith. Perhaps a further reading of the text will bring elucidation:

For by it {faith} the people of old received their commendation. 

By faith we understand that the universe was created by the word of God, so that what is seen was not made out of things that are visible.

By faith Abel offered to God a more acceptable sacrifice than Cain, through which he was commended as righteous, God commending him by accepting his gifts. And through his faith, though he died, he still speaks.

By faith Enoch was taken up so that he should not see death, and he was not found, because God had taken him. Now before he was taken he was commended as having pleased God.

And without faith it is impossible to please him, for whoever would draw near to God must believe that he exists and that he rewards those who seek him. 

By faith Noah, being warned by God concerning events as yet unseen, in reverent fear constructed an ark for the saving of his household. By this he condemned the world and became an heir of the righteousness that comes by faith.

In all of the examples provided, each one is backed up by tangible evidence.

  • The Word of God was spoken throughout history so that those from Adam and beyond knew from whence they came, this being the evidence of testimony.
  • How did Able know what to bring as an offering? Not through the Bible, but by having a living conversation with God – trusting and believing His testimony.
  • Enoch believed and trusted God that he would not see death but be taken up instead. He had reason to believe and trust God’s word.
  • Noah acted on God’s tangible word after being warned and instructed.

A Better Understanding of Faith

In any court, testimony is considered evidence. Even so, without trust there can be no faith.

Suppose you want to hire Yardman to mow your grass, as you have an acre of grass to maintain. To that end, you interview a few people.

The first person arrives with scissors and promises to show up on time every week. He asserts that he will cut your grass with his scissors and be done in about an hour. The second person you interview arrives with useful lawn equipment that seems to be seldom used. Your neighbors have warned you that he’s unreliable and may not show up but only once a month, if that. The third person arrives looking tattered, hot, and with grass clippings stuck in his hair. He provides, like the others, a fair price for the job.

Which one do you hire, and why?

  • You avoid Scissor Man because you don’t believe he can do the job.
  • You avoid Seldom Man because you don’t trust him to do the job.
  • You hire Tattered and Dirty Man because you believe he can do the job and trust that he will keep his word.

So, you hired the Tattered and Diry Man, because why? Because of the faith generated by the evidence provided.

The Scientific Method

Whether supernatural or natural, faith is always based on the evidence provided. It is generated and grows by believing the evidence and trusting its Maker. As such, the Scientific Method is the best example of our generation of natural faith.

Something is observed, and a curiosity is formed along with an idea of why the thing is. Tests are devised and investigated for their applicability and trustworthiness. The tests are performed, and the results are evaluated as conforming to the qualifications previously devised. Once the results are confirmed, we let someone else run the same experiments. The more times they’re run, the more times they show the same results, the more our belief in the original hypothesis and theories increase, along with the trust in the validity of the devised tests. All because of trust placed into the original systems of belief and the qualities of trustworthiness of the tests performed.

We have faith because we know the One who speaks, and we believe because we have found Him to be Trustworthy.

Thus, faith is never blind, regardless of how often someone removes Hebrews 11:1 from its context.

So, the next time someone tells you that faith is blind, ask them if they believe the Bible provides evidence of a Creator, Moral Giver, and Judge. If they assert that as true, then remind them they have simply believed a logical construct, seeing that their faith must, by their definition, be blind.